Why SEO That Used to Work Fails How shifts in the search landscape, marketing channels, & user behavior mean what used to work in SEO, doesn’t anymore.


The Presentation inside:

Slide 0

Rand Fishkin, Wizard of Moz | @randfish | [email protected] Why SEO That Used to Work Fails How shifts in the search landscape, marketing channels, & user behavior mean what used to work in SEO, doesn’t anymore.


Slide 1

bit.ly/whyseofails Get the presentation:


Slide 2

#1 Tactical SEO fails. Strategic SEO works.


Slide 3

SEO as a Tactic: Example: Rand’s new site offering dating advice to Jewish guys I went on dates with four different people from 1995-2001 (then I met Geraldine). I must be qualified!


Slide 4

I want to rank for these keywords. SEO as a Tactic: Controlling your nebbishy nature How to say no to Mom’s setup attempts What is this ‘sports’ thing? How schlubby is too schlubby? Keywords for Menschify.com


Slide 5

I want to grow our search traffic by 33% this year. SEO as a Tactic:


Slide 6

Why Doesn’t This Work? What Changed?


Slide 7

The Ranking Algo Used to Feel Like This: Keyword Matching Domain Authority Link Signals QDF Ranking + + + = Great. Just do that stuff on the pages I told you to rank.


Slide 8

Now It Feels More Like This: Keyword Matching Domain Authority Link Signals QDF (& QDD) Ranking + + + + Uhhh…OK. So just do all that now, right? Intent Matching Topical Authority Usage Signals User Experience + + + = HTTPS, Mobile, +


Slide 9

We Used to Run Marketing Channels as Distinct, Separate Silos Organic Search Social Media Paid Search Email Brand Marketing Offline & WoM Onpage Channels Quality Score List Size & Quality Sentiment Virality Offpage Following Spend Open & Click Rate Reach Distri-bution


Slide 10

Each Channel Contributed Individually to the Whole 3X Organic Search Social Media Paid Search + + =


Slide 11

Then, Some Marketers Realized the Benefits of Channel Integration 6X = Organic Search Social Media Paid Search


Slide 12

This Integration Benefits from Two Trends Search Social Offline Email Content WoM #1: More web users consuming more of these in tandem: #2: Many of these channels directly & indirectly influencing each other:


Slide 13

So What Does Strategic SEO Look Like?


Slide 14

SEO As a Strategy: Audience Amplification Funnel We need to answer questions about each of these to form a coherent SEO strategy


Slide 15

Who is my target customer? And who will eventually become a target customer? Who/what influences my target customers? Audience What channels can I use to reach these three audiences?


Slide 16

Funnel Which parts of our marketing funnel are right for SEO? What problems, questions, or topics do people have that align w/ our goals?


Slide 17

How will we earn the visibility signals necessary to compete? Amplification Why will those who see our work amplify us rather than our competition?


Slide 18

SEO As a Strategy: Audience Amplification Funnel Once you nail these, the tactical to-do list is much easier to create (and much more effective)


Slide 19

#2 Building a well-SEO’d site may be less valuable than building a powerful brand.


Slide 20

2011: I think that’s the only one I’ve heard of…


Slide 21

2015: Hmm… Pretty sure that’s 5 of the 7 largest, best-known auto insurers in the US?


Slide 22

2011: I know Sunset, but none of these others.


Slide 23

2015: This is the only brand on page one I don’t know.


Slide 24

Why? What Changed?


Slide 25

#1: Brands Got Serious About Investing in SEO In years past, big brands didn’t have in-house SEO teams. Today, it’s a standard.


Slide 26

#2: Brands Benefitted from Shifts in Google’s Algo More Links = Higher Rankings Better Links = Higher Rankings Brand familiarity & UX barely influence SEO Usage signals mean brand & UX are powerful influencers Naive KW matching rewards KW-centric SEO Topic & intent-matching reward more holistic content 2015: 2011:


Slide 27

These brand info drop-downs suggest to me Google’s deeply interested in highlighting brands in their SERPs.


Slide 28

In many results, there’s an eerie correlation between high rankings and sites that have the brand drop-down.


Slide 29

Building a well-known brand may soon be a prerequisite for ranking in Google.


Slide 30

#3 Choosing the right keywords is much more complex than in the past.


Slide 31

Old Keyword Prioritization Methodology Term/Phrase Est. Volume Biz Value What’s a Mensch What to wear on a first date Sarmassophobia Kosher date ideas 100/month 1,000/month 20/month 30/month Low Medium Medium High Pri 2 1 5 3 Fear of dating 50/month Medium 4


Slide 32

Why doesn’t this work anymore? What changed?


Slide 33

Even ranking #1 probably won’t get the site many visits.


Slide 34

This SERP has a bias to fresh content and an image block that probably gets a lot of the traffic


Slide 35

It probably makes no sense to target these queries separately


Slide 36

Opportunity seems higher and competition lower than the others keywords…


Slide 37

What Should Keyword Evaluation Look Like in 2015?


Slide 38

New Keyword Prioritization Methodology KW Volume Value What’s a Mensch What to wear on a first date Sarmassophobia Kosher date ideas 100/mth 1,000/mth 20/mth 30/mth Medium Low High High Pri 4 3 1 2 Fear of dating 50/mth High 1 Oppty Features Diff 54% 47% 17% 50% 41% Low Medium High High High KG Images None Forum Sitelinks None


Slide 39

54% 47% 17% 50% 41% New Keyword Prioritization Methodology KW Volume Value What’s a Mensch What to wear on a first date Sarmassophobia Kosher date ideas 100/mth 1,000/mth 20/mth 30/mth Medium Low High High Pri Fear of dating 50/mth High Oppty Features Diff Low Medium High High High KG Images None Forum Sitelinks None These two should be targeted by a single piece of content 4 3 1 2 1


Slide 40

4 3 1 2 1 54% 47% 17% 50% 41% New Keyword Prioritization Methodology KW Volume Value What’s a Mensch What to wear on a first date Sarmassophobia Kosher date ideas 100/mth 1,000/mth 20/mth 30/mth Medium Low High High Pri Fear of dating 50/mth High Oppty Features Diff Low Medium High High High KG Images None Forum Sitelinks None This may not even be a target at all given the low opportunity for traffic


Slide 41

4 3 1 2 1 54% 47% 17% 50% 41% New Keyword Prioritization Methodology KW Volume Value What’s a Mensch What to wear on a first date Sarmassophobia Kosher date ideas 100/mth 1,000/mth 20/mth 30/mth Medium Low High High Pri Fear of dating 50/mth High Oppty Features Diff Low Medium High High High KG Images None Forum Sitelinks None The image block may be an easier target for this query


Slide 42

Keyword Evaluation in 2015 Has to Be Broader to Be Successful Potential Reach (volume) Intent Overlap Opportunity Business Value Verticals/ Features Content Requirements Audience Targeting


Slide 43

#4 Earn links like a publicist, not like a link builder.


Slide 44

Irony: If Anyone Can Get the Link, No One Should Google should really have an answer box here warning searchers against using any of these results


Slide 45

Same story here – chase links like this and Google will make your life rough.


Slide 46

BTW – if you ever want to get around these annoying things, just use Google’s “cache:url” command and hit “Text only”


Slide 47

Every One of These is Dangerous: Article Marketing Private Blog Networks Article Directories Link Directories Web 2.0 Links Article Spinners Xrumer blasts Link Wheels Press Release Submissions Link Pyramids Social Bookmark Links Dofollow Comments SENuke Open Edu/Gov Links Redirection links


Slide 48

When it comes to links, stay away from these verbs and adjectives: Manual High PR Buy Spin Dofollow Submit Blast Multi-tier Expired Domain Inject Separate C-block Private


Slide 49

It’s not just manipulative links – manual link acquisition in general sucks I’ve spent months mastering link building, and can get 2-3 good links/day… why can’t I beat the competition?!


Slide 50

Manual links can’t compete against a scalable flywheel Do Amazing Stuff (content, product, press, events, etc) Get attention from those who can amplify to a bigger audience Grow your amplification abilities (social, blog, RSS, PR, authority from links, etc) Earn more attention, amplification, and growth next time


Slide 51

Manual links can’t compete against a scalable flywheel Do Amazing Stuff (content, product, press, events, etc) Get attention from those who can amplify to a bigger audience Grow your amplification abilities (social, blog, RSS, PR, authority from links, etc) Earn more attention, amplification, and growth next time So that’s why…


Slide 52


Slide 53

Why can’t we “acquire” links? What changed?


Slide 54

1997-2011: Link Spam was Google’s Problem Via the Moz Blog


Slide 55

2012-Present: Link Spam is Our Problem Via Marie Haynes


Slide 56

What kinds of links still work?


Slide 57

Link from a guest post by Geraldine on MarieClaire. The Ones You Earn


Slide 58

Link from an interview by Mashable. The Ones You Earn


Slide 59

Granted, the anchor text is a little weird, but it’s still a great link! The Ones You Earn


Slide 60

This Will Get You in Trouble: Crappy Links Seek out links to rank better Acquire them manually Submit, pay, beg, trade, etc. + + = Low Scalability Risk of Penalties This Will Get You the Right Links: Do stuff worthy of attention Earn amplifi-cation Links come in naturally + + = Traffic Branding Rankings


Slide 61

#5 Nailing SEO might not produce results w/o accompanying user & usage signals.


Slide 62

Say you make some great content, get some great links, and rank here.


Slide 63

But, the piece doesn’t engage visitors (or it loads slow, or doesn’t look right on their device). They click “back” and choose a different result. Unbelievably, eHarmony ranks w/ this awful page (10 signs? They only list 1!!)


Slide 64

But, searchers who click this one engage with it, browse more pages on the site, and don’t repeat the query.


Slide 65

All that effort probably won’t help you maintain those rankings (and having a poor user experience could hurt your whole site in the engines’ eyes)


Slide 66

Why won’t I keep my rankings? What changed?


Slide 67

Search engines call the click-back-and-choose-a-different-result behavior “pogo-sticking,” and they use it in evaluating rankings. Read more about Yahoo!’s Patent Application here.


Slide 68

Read more about Google’s patent application on usage data here. Engines probably also use data related to the visit frequency of pages/sites, so getting traffic from other sources and satisfying those visitors might help your SEO, too.


Slide 69

Perfect Keyword Targeting Domain Authority Loads of Links Anchor Text + + + + Great Content Excellent UX Lots of Traffic High Engagement + + + Schema Markup Might Be Worse Than:


Slide 70

Perfect Keyword Targeting Domain Authority Loads of Links Anchor Text + + + + Great Content Excellent UX Lots of Traffic High Engagement + + + Schema Markup Might Be Worse Than: Smart players will invest in all of these.


Slide 71

#6 SEO might no longer be a great way to get early traction.


Slide 72

Bad biscuits make the baker broke, bro.


Slide 73

Great Biscuits A Brand People Know, Love, & Share Great Rankings


Slide 74

Great Biscuits A Brand People Know, Love, & Share Great Rankings The era of this formula being reversible is disappearing fast.


Slide 75

Rand Fishkin, Wizard of Moz | @randfish | [email protected] bit.ly/whyseofails


×

HTML:





Ссылка: